The Global ARCHICAD Community

Stay informed. Get help. Share your knowledge.

Discussions about any other product with no dedicated forum - MEP Modeler, ARCHICAD Goodies, 3rd-party Add-Ons, operating systems, products of other vendors, etc. (Example: Which Add-On is the best for creating special Stairs?)

Moderators: Karl Ottenstein, LaszloNagy, ejrolon, Barry Kelly, gkmethy

#294230
No, to be truthful, I have to say that the MEP capabilities of Revit are much better/greater than that of the MEP Modeler Add-On for ARCHICAD.
Also, Revit developers annually add new capabilities to its MEP tools, while MEP Modeler has not been developed in any significant way in the last several years.
#294244
I would have to agree with Lazslo that the MEP add on is not as complete as that on Revit but ARCHICAD is not marketed as an engineering tool and does not have its roots in engineering. Revit I believe grew out of Pro/Engineer.
#297128
The big plus of ArchiCAD MEP Add-On - that in ArchiCAD it is possible to create your own library written on GDL. It is a complicated task - to program complex MEP objects on GDL, but the result is great. The big minus - MEP Add-On was not developed for many years, GDL variable structure of MEP objects is very strange, default GDL scripts and macros are very heavy. Also during IFC import ArchiCAD replacing straight pipes with ArchiCAD MEP native pipes (that later can be modified), but all bends and other elements - as static objects. It would be great if Graphisoft continues MEP Add-On development and introduce a new version of it. See attached examples, done by me using ArchiCAD MEP Add-On and custom GDL libraries.
Attachments
Screenshot 2019-05-11 at 08.52.20.png
Screenshot 2019-05-11 at 08.50.57.png