The Global ARCHICAD Community

Stay informed. Get help. Share your knowledge.

Modeling (Wall, Door, Window, Roof, Stair...), Favorites...

Moderators: Karl Ottenstein, LaszloNagy, ejrolon, Barry Kelly, gkmethy

WHAT'S YOUR OPINION ABOUT THIS WISH?

Essential
No votes
0%
Important
No votes
0%
Average
No votes
0%
Not important
2
67%
Not needed
1
33%
By jc4d
#295043
Hi all,

Would it be possible to revamp how the wall works in archicad?. Currently each wall behave as independent object with no correlation with each other, leading to a much more slow designing/ drawing process.

In the current workflow if there are e.g. two walls connected in L shape and one of those is moved the another one is not following keeping the connection alive, this leads to extra steps that are redundant and unnecessary to accomplish one simple task. Therefore, having a setting where the end user wants to keep the connection alive will boost the workflow by releasing the user for calling so many commands to keep the walls connected.

I'm aware that AC has the marquee tool but this affects all the elements that are inside the marquee area which is not what the user is looking after. Naturally, the walls layers can be isolated and then use the marquee tool but this creates again unnecessary step for such a simple task.

Cheers,
Juan
User avatar
By LaszloNagy
#295049
If you select connected Walls before moving the Wall, then ARCHICAD will treat consecutive Wall Reference Lines as a Polyline and you can edit it as a Polyline. If you then offset the Wall using Pet Palette commands, the connected Wall will also adjust in length.
User avatar
By Erwin Edel
#295060
To add to what Laszlo already pointed out, any edges that overlap can be moved with a single offset. So if slab would also be touching that edge of the wall, you can offset that along with the walls. This can even work over multiple stories (group elements in 3D, select group, supend groups and make the offset).
By jc4d
#295062
LaszloNagy wrote:
Mon Mar 04, 2019 12:23 pm
If you select connected Walls before moving the Wall, then ARCHICAD will treat consecutive Wall Reference Lines as a Polyline and you can edit it as a Polyline. If you then offset the Wall using Pet Palette commands, the connected Wall will also adjust in length.
Thank you for the tip, I just tried it and it works but it seems this is not possible for a T junction type.
User avatar
By Lingwisyer
#295095
It is possible to do a T-Junctions using the marquee tool then using Adjust(?) (ctrl + h). You just have to be careful in what falls within your marquee, especially if you are using the "all floor" marquee as any node within the marquee will be moved.



Ling.
By jc4d
#295104
Yes I'm aware of the marquee tool, and that's my point of my wish, to move and/ or offset a wall the must-have to use different ways to accomplish a simple task, walls should be walls.

if is a L-junction the user have to select all the connected walls and offset and if is a T-junction then is marquee tool, so it is not the proper workflow. I have been an VectorWorks user for more than 15 years and now the company I work for uses archicad and I see how all the designers spend valuable time just readjusting and rejoining walls after an offset which translates into waste or productivity time.
User avatar
By Erwin Edel
#295110
You can just use Adjust (CTRL -). Select the wall to extend, click Adjust, select the edge where you want to adjust to.

The Edit Elements toolbar is very handy to have active for Adjust, Intersect, Fillet etc, all the basic 2D linework commands work for walls, beams and other elements I might forget which have a reference line.
By jc4d
#295113
Thanks for the tip, and yes this is the current work, but as you noticed in your description, you need many different clicks and key strokes to accomplish this simple task. Therefore, this is the bottom line of my wish, reduce the amount of clicks and key strokes for such simple task like moving a wall and keep the connected ones connected.
Because if we can at least somehow unify the workflow of moving walls is like no matter how the walls junction are, T, L, or Y, we select the connected walls and perform an offset then in a way is ok workflow, but to experiment different workflow to accomplish the same task is not ideal.